How we review and score an offer

Seven checks, one plain average, and a few rules the average can't override. This page explains exactly how every score on New Skill Notes is produced, and what it does not measure.

9 offers scored

7 checks per score

6.9 average score

67% rated Worth it

What the score measures

The score rates an offer, not a skill outcome. It answers the questions you have before paying: what exactly do I get, what will I be charged, and how do I get my money back if it isn't for me? It does not tell you whether you'll learn Spanish in six months or fix your slice, and no review on this site claims to know that.

Each score is the average of seven sub-scores out of 10. All seven are printed on every review, so you can weigh them differently if your priorities differ from ours.

What we write down

For every offer we open the vendor's sales page and, where we can, the order form the buy button leads to. We record:

  • the price, the currency, and whether tax or shipping is added
  • how you're billed: one payment, instalments, a trial that converts, or a subscription
  • anything offered before or after payment (upgrades, add-ons, recurring extras)
  • the refund window stated on the page, and whether it matches the order form
  • who sells it: a named person or company, and whether that can be traced
  • the format, length and delivery method
  • the date of each check

What the page doesn't say gets recorded too. A missing price, a missing refund window or a missing seller name is a finding, and it is scored.

The seven checks

CheckThe questionScores high whenScores low when
Offer clarityDoes the page tell you what you get and what it costs before checkout?contents, format and price stated on the page.a video or story where the offer should be, or the price only revealed at checkout.
Value for moneyWhat do you get, compared with similar offers?a stated quantity (lessons, hours, files, levels) at or below the going rate.a high price for something short, vague or freely available.
Pricing honestyIs the advertised price what you pay?one clean charge that matches the page.a recurring charge presented like a one-off, a crossed-out "regular price" we can't find evidence of, or prices that differ between listings.
Delivery and accessHow do you receive it, and does access end?instant digital access, format stated, lifetime access.an unnamed format, slow physical shipping, or access that expires.
Refund termsIs there a clear refund window that matches the order form?60 days or more, stated consistently.no window stated, a short window, or terms that differ between page and checkout.
Vendor transparencyCan you tell who's behind it, and can their claims be checked?a named person or company with traceable credentials.a pen name, an anonymous page, or credentials that can't be traced.
Claim disciplineDoes the promise fit what's delivered?promises you can check before buying, like a number of lessons or patterns.outcomes nobody can measure, or results guaranteed in the headline.

From sub-scores to a verdict

The published score is the plain average of the seven sub-scores, rounded to one decimal.

  • Worth it: 6.5 or higher
  • Worth a look: 5.0 to 6.4
  • Skip: below 5.0

Rules the average can't override

Payment and delivery basics are handled well by most marketplaces, so they lift almost every offer's average. To stop that from hiding a weak offer, the verdict has floors:

  • If the seller won't say clearly what the product is (offer clarity 4 or lower), the verdict is Skip.
  • If the main promise can't be true (claim discipline 3 or lower), the verdict is Skip.
  • An offer with offer clarity of 5.5 or lower can't be rated Worth it.
  • To be rated Worth it, an offer needs at least 5 on both offer clarity and vendor transparency. We need to know what it is and who sells it.

The floors change the label, not the number, so you can still see how close an offer came.

Offer reviews and hands-on reviews

Most reviews here are offer reviews: we read the sales page and the order flow, and we say so in a "How we assessed this" box at the top of the page. When we buy and use a product ourselves, the box says "Hands-on review", the page gains a section describing what we did and over how long, and the date of that test is shown. We never present research as personal experience.

Independence and affiliate links

New Skill Notes earns a commission when you buy through some links on this site. That is how the site is funded. The commission rate is not an input to any of the seven checks, vendors can't pay to be reviewed or to change a verdict, and offers with low scores stay published with their reasons. Every offer link is marked as sponsored, and a short note sits next to every buy button. Full details: Affiliate disclosure.

What this method can't tell you

  • Whether the product delivers the result it promises. We read offers; we don't follow every course for months.
  • What the vendor changes after our check. Prices, bonuses and refund windows move, which is why every review is dated.
  • What you'll pay outside the United States. Tax, currency and even the price can differ.
  • Anything about a product we haven't reviewed. Not being on this site isn't a verdict.

Re-checks and corrections

When we notice that a price, a refund window or an order flow has changed, we re-read it, update the review and change its date rather than leaving the old figure. If you spot an error of fact, write to contact@newskillnotes.com with the page address and what you found. We correct facts; we don't change a score because a vendor disagrees with it.

Questions

Do you test the products you score?

Not usually. Most reviews are offer reviews based on the sales page and order flow, and the "How we assessed this" box says exactly what was checked and when. When a review is based on real use, it's labelled as a hands-on review.

Does the commission change a score?

No. The commission rate isn't one of the seven checks, and offers that score badly stay published.

Why do some good products score only "Worth a look"?

Because the score is about the offer. A good course sold with confusing pricing, aggressive upsells or an anonymous seller will lose points on those checks.

Can a vendor ask for a correction?

Yes, for errors of fact. We re-check the page, fix the review and update its date. We don't change scores on request.